(NASHVILLE, TN, October 4, 2007) State Representative Matthew Hill (R-Johnson City) said today he will join colleagues in introducing legislation in the Tennessee General Assembly to curb the “excessive enforcement and surveillance” tactics by the state’s Revenue Department Special Investigations Section of Tennessee residents who buy cigarettes at out-of-state tobacco retailers located near the state line. Hill said he was looking at a couple of legislative options to control these “unreasonable and unbelievable” tactics.
“The efforts by Revenue Commissioner Farr to accost people by placing an ‘SS’ type of ‘Special Smoking’ agents to look over the shoulders of persons buying cigarettes at the market across state lines to see if they are Tennesseans is way out of line with the kind of law enforcement the people of this state expect us to conduct,” said Rep. Hill. “This is not Nazi Germany where the government is looking at every aspect of our lives. We have much more pressing problems than to be utilizing the resources of this state to conduct surveillance and stop citizens to see how many packs of cigarettes they have,” he continued.
Tennesseans may legally possess no more than two cartons of cigarettes without the state tax stamp. Possession of more than two but less than 25 cartons of contraband cigarettes, is a misdemeanor. Possession of more than 25 cartons of untaxed cigarettes is a Class E felony. Any contraband cigarettes and the vehicle in which they were transported are also subject to seizure. Tennessee’s cigarette tax was raised from 20 cents per pack to 62 cents per pack during the 2007 legislative session.
“We can address this problem through legislation changing the amount of cigarettes a person can possess without a state tax stamp before it is considered illegal or we can look at under what circumstances that these agents can cross state lines for collection purposes,” Hill continued. “However, you would think that common sense would prevail and we would not have to resort to this kind of legislation when clearly the efforts should center on those who are in the resale business.”
Rep. Hill said the administration was warned by fiscal experts who said the price hike could provide an incentive for some Tennessee residents to buy cigarettes in neighboring states. The administration expects to raise $239 million in revenues from the tax increase.
“The citizens in my district are outraged that we are putting valuable resources into this type of government surveilance and I don’t blame them. We have one of the highest crime rates in the nation, we have drunk drivers on our highways and we have an illegal immigration problem. To stand on the state line to see how many packs of cigarettes a person bring back is way beyond misuse of taxpayer money and resources.”
October 8, 2007 at 6:48 am
While Rep. Matthew Hill is tilting at windmills(again) in this issue of out-of-state survaillence of cigarette sales by Tennessee Department of Revenue law enforcement officers, you would have why Hill is siding up with organized crime rings involved with cigarette smuggling and underage smokers crossing the state border in his knee-jerk zeal to keep Tennessee revenue officers from enforcing the constitution laws enacted by the Tennessee General Assembly?
And did I mention that numerous published medical studies reveal that smoking is a significant risk factor leading to spontaneous abortion of the unborn? Why is Rep. Matthew Hill in such a rush to propose his new legislation lower the overall price of cigarettes in Tennessee, and at the same time, increase the number of spontaneous abortion of human fetuses…?
This legislator with intent to kill fetuses by cigarettes makes me want to puke…
October 8, 2007 at 7:55 am
I’m with Matthew Hill over the cigarette surveillance. However, what puzzles me is that Rep. Hill has gone on the attack referring to Mr. Farr and his Tenn. Department of Revenue as the SS, and referring to them as Nazis. Two points. All they are doing is carrying out the laws passed by politicians such as Matthew Hill. So, if anybody deserves to be called Nazis, it’s the politicians that passes these laws. Also, in the past, (and I’m banned from WPWT now so I can’t call in), when I refer to George Bush and his minions as Nazis because of their surveillance programs then I was put down and laughed. What’s the gig?? It’s ok for Rep. Hill to refer to government administrators as Nazis but I can’t refer to elected officials as the same? Go figure.
October 8, 2007 at 10:20 am
Welcome back, Gary!
It’s been quiet around here without you…
-J
October 9, 2007 at 5:38 am
In response to ..ahem..Elmer Gantry: Spontaneous abortion of the human fetus caused by cigarettes? OK, but, Mr. Gantry may be interested to know that fully 2/3 of ALL human pregnancies spontaneously abort. (Per an ETSU Embryologist). Why, lets just regulate everything. In fact, 100% of spontaneous abortions occur in women who’ve had sex. If we could just regulate procreation, we could put a stop to this tragedy. What’s the Liberal mantra? “If it saves just one life, isn’t it worth giving up a teeny bit of your freedom?”
Organized crime rings and cigarette smuggling syndicates? Its a good thing that state revenue agents (our new “Cigarette Border Patrol” so to speak) are cracking down on this illict activity. I would hate to think that Tennessee would use these valuable resources fighting petty crime like, I don’t know, maybe…REAL drug smugglers.
This is nothing more than a legalized mafia shakedown via low level Joey-Bag-O-Donuts-muscle, “’cause ‘da Boss sez youz gotta pay up now”. If the Tennessee House of “Boss Hogg” Legislators is willing to go this far over cigarettes, where will it stop? Are groceries cheaper out of state? I’m going to start a Cheerios smuggling syndicate. They sell ‘em cheaper in ‘Bama. I’ll bring ‘em back Dukes-of-Hazard style and get filthy rich…if I can dodge the TNCIU (Cheerios Interdiction Unit, that is). Roscoe P. Coltrane is so proud of those boys.
October 9, 2007 at 11:11 am
Since there is a limit on “legal” cigarettes that can be brought across state lines, what is the limit for bringing illegals across state lines? Wish as much attention, to the latter, was being addressed with as much vigor.
October 10, 2007 at 11:37 pm
Patti, there is no limit on illegals because you can’t smoke them. If you could smoke illegals then Tennesee would actually become concerned because they could TAX them.
October 11, 2007 at 12:13 am
Mark E. posted October 9, 2007 at 5:38 am
“In response to ..ahem..Elmer Gantry: Spontaneous abortion of the human fetus caused by cigarettes? OK, but, Mr. Gantry may be interested to know that fully 2/3 of ALL human pregnancies spontaneously abort.”
Ahh..now I understand…the Far-Right Evangelical “Big-Bang” Theory of Spontaneous Abortion: “Spontaneous Abortion – It Just Happens.”
So Rep. Matthew Hill is merely targeting the other 1/3 fetuses in Tennessee for spontaneous abortion by his helping to increase inexpensive cigarette consumption across the Volunteer State. And who is the “SS”?